Summary: When summer comes around, it's off to the beach for Rosalind . . . and off to Maine with Aunt Claire for the rest of the Penderwick girls, as well as their old friend, Jeffrey.
MY THOUGHTS:
Hooray, at last Jeanne Birdsall has hit her stride with this third installment in the series!
Their father is away on his honeymoon, and Rosalind is visiting New Jersey with Anna, her best friend. With Aunt Claire in charge, the three younger sisters are off for a few weeks to a coastal peninsula town named Point Mouette. To their delight, Jeffrey is able to join them, for his mother and the deplorable Dexter are recent enough newlyweds to relish alone time.
Skye and Jane are stressed for different reasons. Skye has a serious case of nerves because she's now the OAP (Oldest Available Penderwick) for the duration, yet she's lost the list Rosalind wrote for her about Batty's needs. Meanwhile, Jane decides it's time to introduce a love element into her Sabrina Starr stories, but develops an unprecedented case of writer's block. And she falls head over heels for a boy named Dominic, who has that unfortunate combo of gorgeous physique and clueless immaturity shared by many lads his age. Yep, the contrast between practical, no-frills Skye and sentimental, dreamy Jane really works well this time.
Little Batty (who I'm convinced is nowhere near as high-maintenance as her sisters think) makes a new friend and develops a talent for playing music, encouraged by Jeffrey who she still adores. She's breaking the myth that no Penderwick can possibly be a musician.
As for Jeffrey, he has no idea that his world is about to be thoroughly shaken. The unexpected news he receives is equally huge for another character. This thread is the main reason for my high ranking. I could certainly see it coming, but predictability is sometimes a good thing if it makes us hold our breath to prepare for the shockwaves. It feels as if we readers are aware of a missile on its way, which isn't remotely on the characters' radars.
Even other events are more to my liking than before. Until now, I've considered Birdsall unskilled at writing simple, charming chapters. But this time, she's got it. Incidents such as playing music from a boat to basking seals, toasting marshmallows, and selling golf balls are great. Far more evocative than the melodramatic rescues, slapstick stage fright, and overdrawn thief-captures she's offered us in the first two novels.
Shout out to Aunt Claire, who has no idea how much of a camp-mama she'll have to be, but still steps up, even with a crook ankle. Jeffrey is depicted at his most considerate and wistful best. And Jane, simply being herself, adds a dash of comic appeal. She brings zaniness to being a bookworm. I love this paragraph about her inner world, for example.
'Until now, Jane's biggest crushes had been on boys in books, especially Peter Pevensie who became High King of Narnia. There'd been others - Tom Hammond from Leepike Ridge, Finn Taverner from Journey to the River Sea, and though he was so small, Spiller from the Borrowers books.'
(Haha, I'm sure many girl readers would agree with Jane's choice of Spiller, but I'd argue that either Edmund or Eustace may be more appealing choices from the world of Narnia, since Peter is pretty perfect from the outset and needs minimal character development. I've always had a soft spot for boy characters with issues. If I could, I'd discuss the subject further with Jane.)
Bring on the fourth book in the Penderwick series, and hopefully the writing quality will stay at this level.
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
No comments:
Post a Comment