Here is my follow-on from Part One, where I first started discussing this breathtaking American classic. You'll find that here. Now we get into the nitty-gritty of the generational pattern that has been established.
MY THOUGHTS:
The Second Cain and Abel and timshel
We left our warm-hearted and gullible hero with a pair of baby boys and a broken heart.
Adam Trask really takes on the mantle of his Biblical namesake after his move to California. He aims to make his new property in the Salinas Valley a wonderful sight, with windmills, wells, flats of alfalfa, and flower seeds to market. It will be the garden of the district. The plan is shelved for over a decade, as he deals with intense grief after Eve's Cathy's departure. The Trask family move into town but the land is always there, as a backdrop for his sons to unintentionally take upon themselves the Cain and Abel roles.
Once the twins take their places as main characters, the story, already riveting, ricochets up another few notches.
When his sons are babies, Adam is very vocal in his defense of Cain the biblical character. Since that's the case we read on to find out how he could possibly allow another version of the Genesis story to play out beneath his own roof. Although Adam is a far nicer father than his own, and never consciously practices such stinking favoritism, there is a generation gap, a communication gap, and honestly, Adam isn't the brightest tool in the shed. (I'll keep skirting around what actually happens, of course. But it's ingenious writing by Steinbeck, who makes the misunderstanding seem almost inevitable.)
We have Aron, the angelic blonde-haired boy whose rosy idealism may also be his fatal flaw. This kid never considers shades of grey and can't handle it when the utopias he spins are shattered. And then there's Caleb, 'sharp, dark, and watchful', who's used to being overshadowed by his brother. The story indicates that people prefer Aron on sight for the most superficial reasons, but hey, isn't that human nature. Their father's perceptions are also on the shallow side. He tends to idolize Aron (whose outlook is, in fact, fairly narrow and resentful) and regards Cal (whose inner life runs far deeper) as a disappointing fall-short.
Cal considers this a secondary problem to his own secret fear of moral inferiority, which works away on his conscience like corrosive acid. Poor Cal harbors a niggling complex that he is crafty and callous by nature, whereas he longs to be as naturally good, pure, and straightforward as he perceives his brother to be. He tortures himself with the notion that he bears an inheritance from his mother, who aced those negative traits.
Thank heavens for the ever faithful and penetrating Lee, sage and mentor extraordinaire. Lee delves deeply into the Genesis 3 narrative itself, and unearths the Hebrew word timshel with its liberating meaning, 'thou mayest'. Regardless of anyone's genepool or background, there is always freedom to choose the path he treads. This gives a person responsibility to purposefully opt for love and wisdom as their guiding lights.
Indeed, I think the advice Lee gives Cal is ahead of his time. He basically draws from his own home-spun version of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), recommending Cal to re-direct his own automatic thoughts and judgments of his low worth, refusing to buy into them. Lee experiments with tough love, especially when it comes to this young man. From a literary perspective, he sticks his neck out to stop Cal from becoming a tragic hero.
Cathy now goes by the moniker of Kate, and she's become the madam of a whorehouse. This is a community in which the church and the brothel are both fixtures and the same men go to both. At first glance this appears like major hypocrisy, but the narrator points out that in his opinion, both institutions serve the same function. They take a man out of his bleakness with hope and pleasure for a short time.
We know Cathy commits horrific deeds with quiet aplomb. She's never obvious or heavy-handed (which is probably why she didn't pitch the babies into the well as she suggests). We also know that she's wickedly patient in her machinations. In the same chilling style as Heathcliff or Madame Defarge, she will bide her time, then strike. But alcohol is definitely her Kryptonite. Her downfall is bound to come, right? As a person ages so do their possible nemeses, not to mention the pair of growing sons she turned her back on.
While pondering this very post, I came across the rare phenomenon called heteropaternal superfecundation. A mother releases two eggs in the same menstrual cycle. If she has sex with two different men within the same short fertility window, those eggs can be fertilized by different fathers. This is precisely what the diabolical Cathy does when she first marries Adam.
So here is my theory. Just as the first generation of half-brothers in this novel had the same father and different mothers, now it's reversed. The second pair, although twins, shares the same mother but different dads. Perhaps Cal, with his dark shrewdness and exile tendencies, was fathered by Charles. And of course, Aron shares Adam's blinkered naivety, and ironically also his disenchantment with his birth father. There is no firm evidence that Steinbeck intended any such thing. But it's so twisted, potentially scandalous, and perfect for this plot that I'm sticking with this theory as my head-canon.
This is one of the stand-out books of the year for me. Now that I've finished, I can't stop thinking about it. I've long believed the best types of novel are more effective than self-help books. This one allows us to draw deep breaths and extend grace to ourselves for undesirable character traits that pop up, (as they always do), knowing that we are in such good company as Caleb Trask. That poor kid kept a lid on his for such a long time.
Although I winced at a lot that happens, this story is brightened by lighter moments and ends with hope for the future. It doesn't surprise me that John Steinbeck considered this his magnum opus. He'd been writing for a long time at this point and gives us the gamut of his skill, including merry anecdotes, a double biblical epic, frequent humor, and occasional tragic backstories. I love it in the same way that Samuel Hamilton loved Doxology, his ungainly and contrary old horse.
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
Note: Do you fancy an 'East of Eden' treat? If you've loved this novel and would like to read my possible concept of a scenario which might follow on, you'll find it here. But only read it if you've read the book or at least watched the series.







