Each year I aim to include a spooky theme on Halloween week. This year I've decided to extend it throughout the entire month of October. I'll review four witch-themed books back-to-back, but not the popular, spine-tingling type of novel aimed to disturb and unsettle us. I'll focus on insightful vintage reads which encourage us to consider the topic through the lenses of tradition, history, and even Christian faith. Here is my first, second, and third.
MY THOUGHTS:
Wow, The Blue Castle meets Supernatural! This is the sort of refreshing novel where we needn't worry too much about spoilers, because the whole story is contained in several of the blurbs I've come across. As a general summary, a maiden aunt goes to live in the countryside and becomes a witch. I won't tiptoe too lightly as I discuss the plot, because doing so will restrict a lot of its whimsy and fun. But if you're concerned about such things, here is my disclaimer. There are mild spoilers but it probably doesn't even matter.
Now here goes.
In her early years, Laura Willowes is a daddy's girl. The apple of his eye, she keeps house for him to their mutual satisfaction. Her beloved father dies when she is 28 years old, and Laura is absorbed into the clockwork-running household of her older brother, Henry. She becomes a companion to Henry's orderly and pious wife, Caroline. The children call her 'Aunt Lolly' and before long, everyone else calls her Lolly too. Laura's persistent dream of living a simple, leisurely life in the country seems futile. Her identity has dissolved.
Twenty years later, when the kids have all grown up, Laura decides enough is enough. Just because her relatives are set in their ways doesn't mean she needs to follow their example any longer. She buys a guidebook and map to the Chilterns in Buckinghamshire and announces her intention to move to the secluded hamlet of Great Mop, holding out against family resistance. 'No Henry, I love you all, but feel I have lived here long enough.'
Staying put with her London family for twenty years was a suffocating trial, but her family never intended to be stick-in-the-muds. That's what makes it hard to stick to her guns. Caroline is a generous sister-in-law who willingly opens her heart and home to Laura. Even Henry is only taking on the head-of-the-family role which the world tells him is his by right. They aren't to know that the lifestyle they offer stifles Laura's soul.
And little does Laura realize that she'll need to become a witch to guard her peace and quiet. Making a deal with the devil appears to be the only way she'll be able to protect the solitude of the new domain she's worked so hard to acquire. Laura doesn't know she's come to Great Mop to become a witch. She thinks she's come just to be in the country and escape being an aunt.
I love the section when her nephew, Titus, crashes into her new stamping ground at Great Mop. He's delighted that his aunt has discovered such a peaceful, unspoiled place for him to settle down in and write his book. Of course letting Titus stay is out of the question. Laura knows she will sink into her familiar, acquiescent role as this overbearing young man's Aunt Lolly.
Titus has already scared off her hard-earned peace with his BIG friendly presence. Even the woods have changed their character. Yet giving him his marching orders must surely fracture their relationship. It's a delicate matter that requires the subtle power of her newfound witchcraft. Titus will surely leave of his own accord when tiny trials keep piling up.
Titus is one of my favorite characters, and the Great Mop villagers love him too. Once again, it isn't a case of driving out an enemy. Laura knows he'd be crushed if he guessed how annoying she finds him. But she can't possibly tell him that he's ruining everything for her.
Honestly, the introduction of the Satan character can be taken with a grain of salt. The author of all evil is written as a genial gent willing to lend a hand. It is a literary ruse aimed to show just how dire things are, when the only way Laura Willowes can attain the peace and autonomy she craves is to strike a deal with the devil and become a witch. It is a social critique laced with satire.
'It had pleased Satan to come to her aid. She did not see who else would have done so. Custom, public opinion, law, church, and state - all would have shaken their massive heads against her plea and sent her back to bondage.'
It becomes clear that Sylvia Townsend Warner has sneakily drawn from traditional witch stereotypes all along. When Laura realizes her vocation, she considers it more an illumination than a surprise. It explains everything; her fascination with 'rural pharmacopoeia', her brews and distillations, her affinity with deep, quiet, country places. When a tiny kitten appears out of nowhere, he's presumably been assigned as her familiar. Even Laura's looks fit the picture that's been built up. Before she even leaves home, Caroline quietly notices Laura's hook nose and sharp chin, reflecting that when she's ten years older, she'll be positively nut-crackerish.
I'd hoped to find this a pleasant, quirky read, but it amazed me how affirming it is for my present season. Earlier this year, I'd made a stand and stopped doing something I'd done for decades. Laura's story comes as a quiet thumbs up. I have three top take-aways which are counter to some of the habits we're urged to practice in our western world.
1) It's perfectly fine if your current ambition is neither lofty nor showy. If you merely want a quiet, curious, and hidden life, all power to you!
2) Some of us aren't born to be social people, no matter how willingly we try to fit in. Laura finds the witches and warlocks' sabbath she attends no more to her liking than any other ball or party she'd ever been to. She takes it as a sign to be careful not to start deferring to public opinion in her new life, just as she had in her old. Right here is permission not to stretch ourselves. (I doubt I would have liked the sabbath either. What a weird event.)
3) It is more than okay to protect our boundaries. And we needn't feel guilty about thwarting the plans of family and loved-ones if they strike the roots of our own personhood. On the surface, it is easy to reason that Titus has a perfect right to come and live in Great Mop if he feels like it, and Laura should just deal with it. But sometimes selfishness is vital for our peace of mind.
This novel begins in the early twentieth century Edwardian era but was first published in 1926, a restless time in history. It was the simmering interwar era when women, whose efforts had been invaluable in World War One, now chafed at the idea of being pushed back into their boxes and expected to resume their old subservient lives. Warner's protest is up among the most charming I've come across. It includes some stunning nature writing, as she urges us to stay true to our own essential natures. It's a far lovelier and more palatable offering than the outright bitterness some other author might have used to air her grievance.
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟







