Who can resist stories with characters in desperate situations? Whether or not we consider ourselves fans of survival stories in general, we're bound to have read a few. They make compelling page-turners because they feature one or two brave souls who face seemingly impossible odds against nature. Although we'd hate to be in their shoes for real, we're happy enough to place ourselves in their mindsets for as long as we're reading.
Several of my choices feature just one key character alone against the elements. Perhaps that appeals to the introvert side of my nature. Or perhaps there's nothing quite as satisfying as cheering for an intrepid underdog, and who could be more deserving than a loner who prevails against the pitiless elements?
1) Robinson Crusoe
I had to read this classic for Uni and found it exceedingly dull, to be honest. Yet Daniel Defoe's famous hero has made his stamp on our western cultural consciousness for generations. He's the quintessential Brit who cannot be subdued by decades on a desert island. Crusoe adapts to what's around him but retains the faith and proud nationalistic spirit he was born with. By modern standards, his imperial attitude of superiority and dominance isn't the most admirable characteristic. But boy, did it work for our friend Robinson!
2) The Martian
The brilliant and creative astronaut Mark Watney is accidentally stranded on Mars where his crew mates leave him for dead, but manages to keep himself alive with basically nothing but his own desperation and ingenuity. I guess he can thank his seed potatoes, botanical background, self-fertilising toilet habits and seemingly never-ending roll of duct tape. Most of all, Mark proves that an offbeat sense of humour is a strong survival tool. His attitude is always, 'This new development is very bad, and I have no idea what I'll do yet, but I'll think of something or I'm history!' (My review is here.)
3) Life of Pi
Piscine Molitor Patel is a resourceful teenager who not only finds himself stranded in a lifeboat on the vast Pacific Ocean but shares it with a group of zoo animals including Richard Parker, a fierce Bengal Tiger. Pi has to assert himself as the dominant animal on the boat or die. In short, this high school boy must embody the superiority of the human spirit just to stay alive. (See my review.)
4) Piranesi
Not only does this young man have a whopping case of amnesia but he lives in a mansion full of statues and rising tides with the potential to drown or starve him any time. Our boy figures out how to develop his fishing and record keeping skills, and this takes all his time so he can't despair. And it sure helps when he chooses to think of the House as a friendly setting he's cooperating with rather than an enemy he's fighting against. (I've raved about it here.)
5) The Long Winter
There were six members of the Ingalls family in this true story, but they made one unbeatable family unit. These guys were stuck in an isolated town buffeted by blizzards. They were slowly freezing and starving, because the supply train couldn't push through until spring. Electricity to houses was way in the future, so they had to improvise ways to produce heat and food out of practically nothing for month after month, surprising themselves by their ingenuity with buttons and straw. (I've written more about this compelling true story here.)
Whew, now that I think of it, what a great stack to read back to back. If you had to choose just one setting to be dropped into, which would it be? Scorching desert, barren red planet, daunting ocean, frozen snow plain or weird house? I think if I had to choose, I'd join Piranesi in the neverending series of halls with all the statues. Even though it's a horrifying prospect, something about it appeals to me.
Have you any favourites you could add to my list?
I loved The Long Winter. I remember my Mum and Dad reading me all those Laura Ingalls Wilder books when I was a kid - Little House on the Prairie, Little House in the Big Woods. But The Long Winter really stands out as having made an impression :)
ReplyDeleteHi James, that's the only one from this list I've read over and over again. What a classic. I recently saw a photograph of the state of the train tracks at the time.
DeleteThanks Paula! I admit I clicked to read because of the Long Winter being on the top of your stack! One of my favourite re-reads from my childhood. Such tenacity. I'll never forget the coffee grinder.
ReplyDeleteI've never been a fan of loner survival stories - I think they're too close to horror for this home body - but Piranese looks interesting! Thanks.
It will be interesting to hear from people who have gone through the relative privations of long lockdowns - can they bear to read this type or do they find solace in commonality?
Hi Tamara, yes, the Ingalls family sure had to muster every ounce of creativity. I loved the coffee grinder too, and the button lamps and twisted hay. They were amazing.
DeleteI do recommend Piranesi, which is a fascinating character study as much as it is a lone survival story. Worth all the rave reviews it's been getting.
So true what you say. I think some people might be drawn to survival stories over recent years, while others may avoid them for being too close to home 😲
Oooh, what a great theme for a list! The Martian and Piranesi are two of my special favourites, perfect choices both. Most of the others that pop to mind for me are memoirs: Wild by Cheryl Strayed, Educated by Tara Westover (not so much the elements but surviving her family!)... maybe Misery by Stephen King for fiction? I'm not sure how I would've held up against Annie Wilkes!
ReplyDeleteI've had both those memoirs on my radar but am still yet to read them. Glad you recommend them. But yeah, The Martian and Piranesi are both such unique scenarios, they're impossible to forget. Thanks Sheree 😊
Delete